One of my jobs as an NIGMS program director is helping investigators navigate the review process. This includes understanding where their applications will be reviewed and how they can make a recommendation about this assignment.
Applications can be grouped for review by research area or grant mechanism, or as a cohort submitted in response to a specific funding opportunity announcement (FOA). I would like to briefly walk through a few scenarios and share some advice along the way.
The “Review and Selection Process” (V.2) section of FOAs provides clues about where your application will be reviewed. An application can be reviewed at the Center for Scientific Review (CSR) or at an individual NIH institute or center (IC), depending upon the particular FOA. Information about who will review your application is posted in your eRA Commons account soon after it is determined, but you should contact your program director or CSR if you have questions or concerns.
The vast majority of applications received by NIH on topics relevant to NIGMS are in response to “parent” program announcements, such as PA-13-302, for unsolicited R01 applications. Section V.2 of PA-13-302 states, “Applications will be evaluated for scientific and technical merit by (an) appropriate Scientific Review Group(s) convened by CSR.” This means that the application will be reviewed by a regular NIH study section or a special emphasis panel (SEP) with expertise in the research area explored by the application. To identify a possible “review home” for your application, I suggest you peruse CSR’s list of study sections, find the ones that seem most suitable for your application and then use NIH RePORTER to search for funded applications that have been reviewed by those study sections. This will allow you to identify the group of scientists who have the appropriate research expertise to review your application.
Specific requests for applications (RFAs), such as RFA-GM-14-003 (Revisions for Macromolecular Interactions in Cells), are often reviewed together in the IC that issued the RFA. For example, section V.2 of GM-14-003 states, “Applications will be evaluated for scientific and technical merit by (an) appropriate Scientific Review Group(s) convened by the NIGMS.” This means that the NIGMS Office of Scientific Review will organize a review panel to review applications submitted in response to this RFA.
For applications that will be reviewed by groups convened by CSR, I encourage the investigators I speak with to write a brief cover letter for their applications that indicates which study section they think is appropriate and how they arrived at that conclusion. Sometimes, it is also helpful to indicate the type(s) of expertise you believe is needed to review your application, but you should not provide a list of reviewers, as that creates issues with potential conflicts of interest. The recommendations made in the cover letter are advisory, but the CSR Division of Receipt and Referral makes every effort to accommodate reasonable requests.
4 Replies to “Identifying the Study Section for Your Application”
For unsolicited applications there is a tool in the eRA Commons called “LIKETHIS” that uses text mining technologies to match an applicant’s Title, Abstract and Specific Aims to funded NIH grants. In the information that is returned in a hitlist are the Study Sections that reviewed the funded grants. These study sections are excellent starting points for applicants to begin their investigation of study sections.
The link to the LIKETHIS tool is found near the bottom of the “Additional Links” list on the right hand side of the Commons Home Page. The instructions on how to use the eRA Commons LIKETHIS feature can be found here: https://era.nih.gov/newsletters/handy_tips.cfm
The advice to go to CSR; then look up study sections and the grants they funded is USELESS without links as to how to do that.
To use NIH RePORTER to search for funded applications reviewed by specific study sections:
Go to the main query page.
Scroll down to the “Study Section” field and click “Select.”
Check/uncheck specific study sections and click “Select.”
If you’re ready to run the query, click “Submit Query” to see a list of grants reviewed by the selected study section(s).
Thank you. This is very helpful. Otherwise, we do not know how to use it. We appreciate your note!